Medicare Part D Plan Comparison Calculator: Compare Annual Drug Costs
Use this guide to understand the assumptions, inputs, results, and next steps behind the calculator.
Created by Luis Gonzalez · Last updated May 2, 2026
A Medicare Part D plan’s lowest premium is not necessarily its lowest total cost. Your annual spending depends on the premium, deductible, copays or coinsurance, and how your prescriptions are assigned to plan tiers. This calculator compares two plans using your monthly retail drug costs by tier and each plan’s benefit terms.
The supplied defaults specify Plan A’s $50 monthly premium, $0 deductible, tier copays of $0, $10, and $40, and tier 4 and 5 coinsurance of 35% and 25%. The drug assumptions are $10 monthly retail cost for tier 1, $30 for tier 2, and $100 for tier 3, with no tier 4 or 5 drugs. The Plan B defaults are truncated, so its complete cost terms are unavailable. No precomputed results were supplied; do not infer which plan is cheaper without entering both plans’ missing terms.
Enter both plans and your medication mix
Enter each plan’s monthly premium, deductible, tier 1–3 copays, and tier 4–5 coinsurance. Then enter the monthly retail cost of medications in each tier. If you have several drugs in one tier, add their retail costs together.
Check that the plans use the same drug list, dosage, pharmacy assumptions, and coverage year. A drug’s tier can differ between plans, and a plan may apply prior authorization, quantity limits, or step therapy. The calculator compares costs from the inputs; it does not verify a formulary or confirm that a pharmacy is in network.
Use the Medicare Plan Finder to check your medications and pharmacies. For a separate estimate of premium-related costs, see the Medicare Part D premium calculator, and use the Part D coverage gap calculator to explore phase-based drug spending.
What the comparison counts
The model calculates an annual total for each plan, then identifies the lower-cost plan and the dollar difference. Its output cards show the cheaper plan, annual savings, and Plan A and Plan B totals.
In general, the plan total combines annual premiums with modeled prescription cost-sharing. The deductible reduces the amount of drug spending subject to copay or coinsurance, while copays and coinsurance depend on the tier. The exact deductible allocation and plan-phase implementation should be checked against the calculator’s detailed result and current plan documents.
The model also calculates annual retail drug cost by adding monthly costs across tiers and multiplying by 12. Retail cost is not the same as what you pay. It is an input describing the medication cost base; the plan’s premium, deductible, tier-sharing, and applicable coverage rules determine estimated member cost.
This comparison does not include every possible Part D expense. Verify additional coverage phases, pharmacy pricing, supplemental benefits, and income-related adjustments. For Medicare medical coverage costs, compare Medicare Advantage and Original Medicare separately; Part D drug coverage is a distinct part of the budget.
Formula: annual cost by plan
The comparison first calculates each plan’s total annual cost, then compares the totals.
Annual premium = monthly plan premium × 12
Annual plan cost = annual premium + modeled annual prescription cost-sharing
For drugs in a tier with a flat copay, the general cost-sharing logic is:
Tier copay cost = number of fills × copay per fill
For a tier priced using coinsurance:
Coinsurance cost = eligible drug cost × coinsurance rate
Finally, the cheaper plan and difference are selected:
Annual savings = higher annual plan cost − lower annual plan cost
Cheaper plan = plan with the lower annual total
If both annual totals match, the result is a tie and savings are $0. The calculator’s exact outputs depend on the missing Plan B inputs and complete default structure; no dollar winner can be stated from the supplied data.
Worked arithmetic using the supplied Plan A inputs
Plan A’s specified monthly premium is $50. Its annual premium is:
$50 × 12 = $600 annual premium
The listed monthly retail drug costs total $140:
$10 + $30 + $100 + $0 + $0 = $140 per month
$140 × 12 = $1,680 annual retail drug cost
Those figures are not the same as Plan A’s annual cost. The deductible and tier cost-sharing determine the member’s drug expense, and Plan B’s complete inputs are required to calculate the winner. The listed Plan A tier 1 copay is $0, tier 2 copay is $10, and tier 3 copay is $40, but fill count and the exact calculation treatment must match the plan’s benefits. Do not apply a copay to the retail amount as if it were a percentage.
Compare different plan and drug scenarios
The table uses distinct illustrative inputs to show why the comparison must use both plan terms and prescriptions. Rows are scenarios, not computed calculator results; actual totals require complete benefit inputs.
| Scenario | Monthly premium | Monthly drug costs by tiers 1/2/3 | What to compare |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | $50 | $10 / $30 / $100 | Supplied Plan A pattern; annual premium is $600 and retail drug total is $1,680. |
| B | $25 | $0 / $60 / $200 | Lower premium but more tier 2 and 3 use; compare the copay burden. |
| C | $65 | $20 / $0 / $40 | Higher premium with lower tier 2 and 3 exposure; may suit a different medication mix. |
| D | $40 | $0 / $0 / $250 | Heavy tier 3 use makes that plan’s tier 3 copay especially relevant. |
A premium-only comparison would favor Scenario B, but it cannot establish the lowest annual cost. A high copay for a frequently used medication can outweigh a premium advantage. Conversely, a more expensive premium may not pay off if the drugs are inexpensive and mostly generic.
Plan details that can change the result
Formularies and cost-sharing can change each year. Review the Annual Notice of Change and compare the plan’s 2026 formulary with your medication list. Confirm whether each prescription is covered, which tier applies, and whether the plan requires prior authorization or a specific pharmacy.
Copays usually charge a fixed amount per fill; coinsurance charges a percentage of an eligible drug cost. Those structures behave differently when a drug price changes. For specialty drugs, a coinsurance percentage can create a large bill even when the plan premium is competitive.
A plan may also have a deductible that applies only to certain tiers or drugs, depending on its approved benefit structure. Use the exact plan document rather than assuming every prescription follows the same deductible rule. If the result appears inconsistent with your plan’s quoted pharmacy price, check whether retail cost, negotiated price, and member cost were entered in the correct fields.
Medicare’s Plan Finder lets you compare current plans using your drug list. If you missed a coverage window, check the Part D late enrollment penalty calculator to estimate a possible surcharge.
FAQs about comparing Part D plans
Should I choose the plan with the lowest premium?
Not automatically. Compare annual premiums plus your expected prescription cost-sharing for the same drugs and pharmacies. A lower premium can be outweighed by a deductible or higher copays.
What does the calculator mean by retail drug cost?
It is the medication cost input used to model plan cost-sharing, not necessarily the amount you pay at the pharmacy. Actual negotiated prices and member costs depend on the plan, drug, and pharmacy.
Can I enter more than one medication in a tier?
Yes. Add the monthly retail costs of medications in the same tier and enter the combined amount. Recheck the tier assignment for each prescription in the plan’s formulary.
Does the calculator guarantee a drug is covered?
No. It compares the assumptions entered; it does not look up plan formularies or coverage restrictions. Verify each medication in the Medicare Plan Finder.
Why can’t the default result identify the cheaper plan?
The supplied Plan B details are incomplete, and no precomputed result is available. Enter Plan B’s premium, deductible, and tier cost-sharing to calculate a meaningful comparison.
Should I favor copays or coinsurance?
It depends on the drug and its price. A fixed copay makes your share more predictable; coinsurance can be lower or higher depending on the eligible cost. Compare the actual prescriptions you use rather than choosing by benefit label alone.
Do Part B premiums belong in this comparison?
No. This calculator compares Part D plan premiums and modeled prescription costs. Include Part B separately using the Medicare Part B premium calculator.
Next steps: compare your actual prescriptions
Gather your drug names, dosage, refill frequency, preferred pharmacies, and each plan’s 2026 benefit terms. Enter the same information for both plans and compare annual totals—not premiums alone. Verify the result through Medicare’s Plan Finder, then add Part B, supplemental coverage, and other healthcare spending to your retirement budget. The Medicare cost estimator by age calculator can help place drug costs in a broader Medicare estimate.